When it comes to choosing between Cinque Terre and the Amalfi Coast, the decision isn't easy. Both destinations offer incredible views, delicious local cuisine, and unforgettable self-guided hiking experiences. However, each has its unique charm and special features. Let's break down the key aspects to help you decide which coastal paradise suits you best.

The Destination 

Cinque Terre 

Cinque Terre, a collection of five colorful cliffside villages, is nestled along the rugged Italian Riviera coastline. This UNESCO World Heritage Site is known for its unique blend of coastal and mountainous landscapes. Each village - Monterosso al Mare, Vernazza, Corniglia, Manarola, and Riomaggiore - has its own character and charm, connected by well-marked hiking trails that offer stunning views of the Ligurian Sea. 

Discover our guide to hiking in Cinque Terre for more advice, tips and inspiration.

Amalfi Coast 

The Amalfi Coast, another UNESCO World Heritage Site, is renowned for its dramatic scenery and cultural heritage. Stretching from the Gulf of Naples to the Gulf of Salerno, this region is dotted with romantic fishing villages like Amalfi, Ravello, and Positano. The Amalfi Coast's landscapes are a striking mix of cliffs, lush greenery, and azure waters, offering panoramic views at every turn. 

Discover our guide to hiking the Amalfi Coast for more advice, tips and inspiration. 

The Self-Guided Hiking 

Cinque Terre 

Cinque Terre is a hiker’s dream, with trails that meander through lemon groves, olive orchards, and vineyards. The most famous route, and the one our Cinque Terre trips journey along, is the Sentiero Azzurro (Blue Path), which connects all five villages and provides spectacular sea views. Browse our Cinque Terre hiking trips and discover your next Italian adventure. 

Amalfi Coast 

On the Amalfi Coast, the ‘Sentiero degli Dei’ (Path of the Gods) is the crown jewel of hiking trails. This path offers awe-inspiring views of the Gulf of Naples, Capri, and Mount Vesuvius. The trails here are well marked and lead through terraced vineyards, historic towns, and coastal cliffs. Whether you choose to explore the coastal paths or venture into the mountains, the diversity of landscapes keeps every hike exciting. 

Browse our Amalfi Coast hiking trips for the Ultimate Italian self-guided hiking trip. 

 
The Food and Drink 

Cinque Terre 

Cinque Terre is a food lover’s paradise. Indulge in freshly caught seafood, locally made pesto, and focaccia bread. Pair your meals with local wines like Sciacchetrà, a sweet dessert wine produced in the region. The cozy cafés in each village offer the perfect spots to relax and enjoy the culinary delights. 

For restaurant recommendations, head to our best restaurants in Cinque Terre article. 

Amalfi Coast 

The Amalfi Coast is famous for its lemon groves and the production of limoncello, a zesty lemon liqueur. The regional cuisine here includes dishes featuring fresh seafood, pasta, and locally grown produce. Don’t miss out on trying 'sfogliatella', a traditional Neapolitan pastry, and enjoy a glass of wine from the vineyards of Aglianico or Falanghina. 

For restaurant recommendations, head to our food and drink on the Amalfi Coast article. 

The Culture and Experiences 

Cinque Terre 

Cinque Terre offers a more intimate and relaxed cultural experience. Explore the narrow streets of each village, visit the picturesque harbor town of Portofino, and discover the artist’s haven of Portovenere. The local festivals and friendly accommodations make it easy to immerse yourself in the Italian way of life. 

Amalfi Coast 

The Amalfi Coast is vibrant and luxurious, attracting visitors from around the world. Visit the medieval town of Ravello with its stunning gardens, take a boat trip to the island of Capri, and explore the ancient ruins of Pompeii. The Amalfi Coast’s combination of history, luxury, and natural beauty provides endless opportunities for exploration. 

Discover best sights to see on the Amalfi Coast in our Things to do on the Amalfi Coast blog. 

The Best Time to Visit 

Cinque Terre 

The best time to visit Cinque Terre is during the shoulder seasons of spring (March to June) and fall (September to October). The weather is pleasant, and the trails are less crowded. Summer can be quite busy, but the lively atmosphere and warm temperatures make it a great time for a coastal adventure. 

Amalfi Coast 

The Amalfi Coast shines during the late spring and early fall months. May, June, September, and October offer warm weather without the peak summer crowds. If you prefer a quieter experience, visiting in the early spring or late fall can provide a peaceful retreat. 

Getting There 

Cinque Terre 

Cinque Terre is accessible by train, with regular services running from major cities like Milan, Florence, and Pisa. The closest major airports are Pisa International Airport (PSA) and Genoa Airport (GOA), which are both approx. 1 hour and 20 minutes away by train. Traveling between the villages is easy via the local train service, hiking trails, or ferry. 

Amalfi Coast 

To reach the Amalfi Coast, fly into Naples International Airport. From there, you can take a train to Salerno and then a ferry or bus to your final destination. Alternatively, hire a car for a scenic drive along the coast. The Amalfi Coast is well connected by public transport, making it easy to explore the region. 

Recommendations 

For Coastal Charm: Choose a self-guided Cinque Terre hiking trip for a combo of bustling charming towns and quieter, stunning coastal hikes. 

To discover more about our Cinque Terre vacations, head to our Guide to Hiking in Cinque Terre for tips, advice and inspiration. 

For Vibrant Luxury and History: Opt for the Amalfi Coast if you prefer a blend of luxury, vibrant culture, and historical exploration with breathtaking views. 

To discover more about our self-guided Amalfi Coast hiking vacations, head to our Guide to Hiking the Amalfi Coast for tips, advice and inspiration. 

Both destinations offer unique and unforgettable experiences. Whether you choose the colorful villages of Cinque Terre or the dramatic cliffs of the Amalfi Coast, Italy’s coastal wonders are sure to leave you with lasting memories. 

Ready to plan your adventure? Book a call with one of our experts to start crafting your perfect Italian getaway today!